Study on the etching conditions of polycarbonate detectors for
particle analysis of safeguards environmental samples
 
K. Iguchi, K. T. Esaka, C. G. Lee, J. Inagawa, F. Esaka, T. Onodera, H. Fukuyama, D. Suzuki, S. Sakurai, K. Watanabe, S. Usuda
Department of Environmental Sciences, Japan Atomic Energy Research Institute,Tokai, Naka, Ibaraki 319-1195, Japan.
Introduction
Conclusion
 The etching time for detection of particle of interest was changed by the enrichment of fissile material in the particle. The results obtained suggest the possibility of
 The screening of the uranium particles according to their enrichment by controlling  the etching time.
 The improvement of efficiency of the particle analysis.
A fission track event from a uranium particle observed by a digital
 microscope.  The uranium particle located at the center (a) and
 fall off from the event (b).
Fission track events
10 mm
(a)
10 mm
(b)
    Environmental sample analysis technique was adopted by the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) as one of new techniques for the strengthened safeguards system.  Its aim is to find undeclared nuclear activities and materials based on isotope ratio analyses of nuclear materials taken from the inside and outside of nuclear facilities.  One of the particle analysis techniques for individual particle analysis is based on fission track (FT) technique combined with thermal ionization mass spectrometry (TIMS).  The FT-TIMS method enables us to analyze sub-micrometer particles containing fissile material.  Recently, we simplified FT-TIMS method ; the particles are recovered from the swipe sample onto the polycarbonate membrane filter by a suction pump.  The filter is dissolved in organic solvent to form a detector of a thin film, in which particles are confined.  The detector is irradiated by thermal neutrons and then etched with NaOH solution. The particles containing fissile materials are detected simply and sensitively with a microscope.  It was found, however, that the particles in the vicinity of the detector surface were often lost during the etching process.  It is expected that the particles in the environmental samples contain uranium of various 235U enrichment (235U/238U ratio). To detect fissile materials in safeguards environmental samples with high detection efficiency and less particle loss, basic data for optimization of the etching condition is required.
 In this work, etching experiments were carried out with uranium particles of various enrichment to investigate the relation between the etching time and the observed fission tracks. 
The character and problem of the detector
Proceeding
Purpose of this study:
To investigate the relation of etching time and the observed fission tracks to obtain appropriate etching condition with high detection efficiency and less particle loss.
Thermal neutron
 irradiation
The particle in the vicinity
 of the surface falls off.
Fission tracks are created
in the direction of 4π
Simple and high sensitive detection
Particle loss
FT detector
Etching
Particles containing fissile materials
Enrichment
higher
The number of FT
larger
The damage around the particle
In this work, we focused on the influence of
 the enrichment to etching condition.
Influence of enrichment and particle size in etching time of detector
Particle size
larger
 bigger
Higher etching rate
Behaviors both the detection of particles and the particle loss are strongly dependent on the enrichment.
(a)
(b)
The changes in the proportions of each events
  This result suggests the possibility that the uranium particles are screened according to their enrichment, by controlling the etching time.
The initial time to detect the events both with a particle and  without a particle are different to the etching time and uranium enrichment. And, the hatched region shows the range in which particle detection without particle loss is possible.
The correlation between the enrichment and the etching time in detection of events with a particle and without a particle.
of etching
Results and Discussion
 The changes in the number and proportion of events
  The number of the events with particles increased steeply after the etching time of 3 min, reached to saturation, and then began to decreases after 14 min. 
On the other hand, the number of the events without particles monotonically increased after the etching time of about 8 min.
Fig. 2
Fig. 1
Fig. 3
Fig. 4
Experimental
Thermal neutron
irradiation at JRR-4
Fluence: 8×1014 cm-2 
Chemical etching:
6M NaOH at 55℃
Dissolution of a polycarbonate
filter with particles by using a mixed solution of dichloromethane
and dichloromethane
Observation of fission tracks
by a digital microscope
(VHX100, Keyence Co.)
Formation of the detector of a thin film
Recover of particles by the filtration
Swipe sample
Filtration
Pump
Polycarbonate
filter
Support
screen
Preparation of FT detector
Samples
   ・NBL950a (natural uranium), NBL U050, U100, U350, U850 ( 5, 10, 35, 85% 235U enriched uranium) swiped with cotton cloth (Tex Wipe®304, 10×10  cm2).
   ・It was confirmed by a scanning electron microscope (JSM6700F, JEOL Inc.) that the uranium-oxide samples used in this study had a similar distribution in particle diameter,
   main part of which is in the range from 1 to  3 mm.
(a)
(Natural uranium)